Test record
Task: _________________________
Prompt version/date: _________________________
Product/model/version (if known): _________________________
Inputs: _________________________
| Test | Expected | Observed | Pass/fail | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typical | ||||
| Missing info | ||||
| Conflict | ||||
| Edge case |
Scorecard
Score 0–2: 0 = missing/incorrect; 1 = partial; 2 = met with evidence.
| Criterion | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy | ___ | |
| Instructions | ___ | |
| Completeness | ___ | |
| Relevance | ___ | |
| Honest uncertainty | ___ | |
| Sources (if relevant) | ___ | |
| Format | ___ | |
| Safety/privacy | ___ | |
| Total /16 | ___ |
Revision
Failure: __________________________
Change made: __________________________
Expected improvement: __________________________
Retest result: __________________________
Remaining limitations: __________________________
Scores are judgments, not objective truth—explain them.